Hiring manager refuses to hire his cousin, Evan, after HR catches the 24-year-old lying on his résumé, choosing integrity over nepotism: ‘Now my aunt and mom are furious with me for “humiliating” him’

This story is fairly simple: Cousin lies on a résumé, gets caught by people whose literal job is to notice lies, then acts shocked when the family hookup decides not to stake his career on a fake degree and a pretend agency job. That is not betrayal, that is basic survival in a place where HR keeps receipts and does not care about Aunt Linda's feelings.

I'm all for helping friends and family, the job market is, well, not the best we've seen to say the least. Bur, and this is a big but, family loyalty always sounds nobler when no one mentions the part about fraud. 

This is a classic "family first" myth colliding with corporate reality. At home, family means you look the other way, smooth things over, and in this case, say he just "rounded up" his experience. At work, family means absolutely nothing when the numbers and dates do not match. HR does not care that you once shared a trampoline; they care that he lied on paperwork with the company logo on top. The minute you vouch for that, the lie becomes yours, not just his.

Like what you see? Follow our WhatsApp channel for more.

Author image for Etai Eshet Etai Eshet
Advertisement

  • AITJ for not giving my cousin a job at my company after he lied on his résumé?

    Frustrated man sitting on couch looking annoyed reviewing confusing paperwork while working on his laptop at home.
    via fizkes

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • Advertisement

  • Evan calling you a corporate sellout is just code for you refusing to be his human shield. The aunt and mom fury is predictable: easier to blame the responsible adult than the grown man who inflated his résumé like a pool float. They wanted nepotism with no consequences, a cute little inside favor that magically never blows back.

  • I (33M) work as a hiring manager at a mid-sized marketing firm. My cousin "Evan" (24M) recently applied for a junior position.
    via EducationalChemist14
  • He told me he had a degree and a year of agency experience. During screening, HR flagged inconsistencies, turns out, he never graduated and exaggerated his previous role.
    via EducationalChemist14
  • Frustrated man reading a confusing document while working on his laptop at home
    via fizkes

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • Advertisement
  • I called him privately, and he admitted it but said, "Come on, it's family. Just push it through." I told him I couldn't do that, I'd risk my own job.
    via EducationalChemist14
  • He said I was "a corporate sellout" who "forgot where I came from." Now my aunt and mom are furious with me for "humiliating" him.
    via EducationalChemist14
  • Shocked man looking at a confusing document while working at his laptop, raising his hand in disbelief.
    via fizkes

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • Advertisement
  • AITJ?
    via EducationalChemist14

  • The truth is ugly but simple. If he wants a job there, he can start by telling the truth. Family connection might open a door, but it does not rewrite HR policies, and it definitely should not cost you your own paycheck.

  • Chance-Yak-8852 NTA. You didn't embarrass him, he embarrassed himself. Family doesn't mean compromising ethics.
    via EducationalChemist14
  • Irishwatcher You should tell your mom and aunt that HR already flagged his résumé and that would they be happier if you were also unemployed because you tried to push it through when they already know he's lying.
    via EducationalChemist14
  • Advertisement
  • RJack151 NTJ. Tell him and your aunt that HR flagged inconsistencies and see that he lied. So with his integrity in question, you cannot push his application through.
    via EducationalChemist14
  • Erotic ChainsawPrinc Nah, NTA man. He lied, u did ur job end of story. Fam gotta realize biz =! family favors. Stand ur ground, dude
    via EducationalChemist14
  • MsPB01 "He 'embarrassed' himself by lying and would YOU pay ALL my bills if I got fired for letting him get away with it?"
    via EducationalChemist14
  • Advertisement

Stay up to date by following us on Facebook!

Tags

terrible coworkers workplace discussion employment issues workplace-stories hr manager hiring manager mother work coworkers hiring colleague aunt workplace work-life balance cousins
Scroll Down For The Next Article

Also From FAIL Blog

Employee confronts boss after discovering that he has been stealing from employee's 401k account for over a year: '[I'm] contacting a lawyer!'

Employee confronts boss after discovering that he has been stealing from employee's 401k account for over a year: '[I'm] contacting a lawyer!'

Trending Now

Employee gets offered another job with higher pay, leaves new job after only two weeks, manager gets offended: ‘I laughed and explained what I was offered’

Employee gets offered another job with higher pay, leaves new job after only two weeks, manager gets offended: ‘I laughed and explained what I was offered’

01
‘Hire me and then I will fix it’: Job candidate finds a bug in company’s data dashboard during the interview, hiring manager demands they provide notes on how to fix the issue

‘Hire me and then I will fix it’: Job candidate finds a bug in company’s data dashboard during the interview, hiring manager demands they provide notes on how to fix the issue

02
29-year-old bartender stuck on closing shift gets even with work enemy by sabotaging her opening shift the next morning: '[She] completely has it out for me'

29-year-old bartender stuck on closing shift gets even with work enemy by sabotaging her opening shift the next morning: '[She] completely has it out for me'

03
Burt-out employee trains her helpless coworker for 9 months, quits just to get away from her when she still won't stop asking questions, leaving her helpless: 'Everything I had taught her seemed to go in one ear and out the other'

Burt-out employee trains her helpless coworker for 9 months, quits just to get away from her when she still won't stop asking questions, leaving her helpless: 'Everything I had taught her seemed to go in one ear and out the other'

04
29-year-old refuses to come to Thanksgiving this year because he and his partner don’t want to do the dishes: ‘We are the only people ever expected to help’

29-year-old refuses to come to Thanksgiving this year because he and his partner don’t want to do the dishes: ‘We are the only people ever expected to help’

05
Team working 50 hours per week all quit at the same time: 'If there's anything we can do to keep you, let me know'

Team working 50 hours per week all quit at the same time: 'If there's anything we can do to keep you, let me know'

06
Advertisement